Sense-making: Leading when the plan stops working

I recently joined Dominique Binns and FJ Hoets on the Risk It for a Biscuit podcast to talk about sense-making as a leadership competency. You can watch the full conversation here. This post pulls together the main threads.

This picture was created with ChatGPT as due to confidentiality I can’t share pictures of the actual cruise ship or oil rig.

Early in my career I worked as a medic on a cruise ship. One day three crew members collapsed in the engine room. It was called in as a medical emergency, the doors were opened, and everyone rushed in, including the medical team. It was a gas leak. The call over the tannoy changed to a fire, which it also wasn’t. By the end, three people had died and 50 had to be medically evacuated. No one took control of the scene, no one was communicating, and no one knew who was in charge.

A few years later I was on an oil rig, sitting on top of all the oil pumped from the surrounding platforms, when we had a gas leak. It should have been terrifying. Instead it felt almost calm. People went up and down the stairs on the left, as they always did, which left the right side clear for the fire team and their hoses. No one had to shout instructions. Everyone simply did what had already become habit.

It took me years, and eventually a PhD on how emergency teams in Cape Town make sense, to understand the difference between those two days. The short answer is sense-making.

Enough sense to act

Dave Snowden defines sense-making as how we make sense of the world so that we can act in it. This implies that sense-making is shaped by identity and by the filters we bring – the ‘who’ is trying to make sense. We see what we are primed to see, and if we don’t think something is our job, we often don’t see it at all.

Second, we only make enough sense to act. We don’t wait for the full picture. Gary Klein discovered this in the 1980s when he rode along with fire commanders expecting to find rational option-weighing. When he asked a commander where his procedures were, the commander tapped his head. Decision-making can be sequential and mapped out when there is time. Sense-making is messier, happens in the moment, and can be primed beforehand.

Not every situation is the same

This is where the Cynefin framework helps. Some situations are predictable: a resuscitation trolley must be checked and stocked, so a checklist and a firm rule work well. Others are still fairly predictable but need some judgement, so good practice and algorithms with room for autonomy make sense.

Then things become unpredictable. Two resuscitations arrive at once, hands run out, the trolley is used up, and people need to improvise. Here rigid procedures help less than a few simple rules everyone shares, plus multiple perspectives. And in true chaos, someone needs to act decisively to stabilise things.

The point for leaders is that one leadership style does not fit all of these. The skill is recognising which situation you are in and adjusting.

Plans are frames

Plans are valuable, but a plan is a frame for the best-case scenario. Karl Weick’s studies of disasters keep returning to the same pattern: people held on to a plan, or to their picture of the situation, after it had stopped fitting reality.

The Mann Gulch fire of 1949 is the classic example. Sixteen smokejumpers dropped into what they thought was a routine fire. When the fire turned, their foreman told them to drop their tools and later lit an escape fire. Both orders made sense. But the crew couldn’t let go of their frame, and they didn’t know or trust a leader they had only just met. Thirteen of them died. (I’ll posting a blog about this soon)

So we need to practise the plan, and we also need to practise recognising when to abandon it.

Sense-making is social

Sense-making is not something a leader does alone. When a situation becomes unpredictable, the different things people notice are your most valuable information. Disaster investigations often find that a junior person saw the warning sign and spoke up, but wasn’t heard.

That is why aviation built crew resource management, and why the WHO surgical safety checklist starts with everyone in theatre introducing themselves by name. Klein’s simple briefing tool works in the same spirit: give everyone a moment to say what they think is going on, what they think we should do, and why.

It is also why I’d describe the leader’s role in complexity differently. Studies of the 9/11 response found many commanders giving orders, and very few people coordinating between teams. In a hastily formed network, the leader’s job is to connect, coordinate and collaborate.

The environment speaks louder than the invitation

During my PhD, a doctor asked me why nurses wouldn’t speak up in meetings that were meant to be a safe, equal space. We walked through their day. Doctors came to work, usually in their own car, parking close to the door and used the front entrance. Nurses came by public taxi, entered through the back entrance of the hospital, walked past a poster listing every uniform rule they could be disciplined for, and drank sachet coffee while the doctors used a coffee machine. Everything in that environment told the nurses they were not equal. One meeting could not undo that.

If you want people to speak up in a crisis, look at what your environment is already teaching them (before the crisis).

What leaders can do now

  • Prepare before the crisis. Weekly, low-stakes simulations build habits, and they build the trust that makes people follow you when it counts.
  • Debrief the thinking, not just the actions. Ask people what they saw, what they missed and why they acted as they did. Let them talk you through their thinking, not their ability to follow the algorithm.
  • Build a few simple rules. Keep left on the stairs. Always check ABC. People can improvise safely inside them.
  • Gather perspectives deliberately. Like Churchill, seek out people who will push back.
  • Value range. People with varied experience often connect the dots faster than narrow specialists when things become uncertain.
  • Start with your own team. You don’t need to change the whole organisation. Change the culture closest to you, and let it spread.

The pace and complexity of change mean no single leader can see the whole picture any more. That isn’t a weakness to hide. It is the starting point for leading well.

If you are working with a team that needs to make sense of a complex or high-pressure situation, I’d be glad to talk. Get in touch.


Discover more from Dr Charmaine Cunningham

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Dr Charmaine Cunningham

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading