Weick on enacted sense-making

It’s 2am on Saturday night in a Cape Town emergency department (ED). The 20 bed unit has 70 patients and is bursting out of its seams. A team member describes it as: “multiple resuscitations at one time with at least two patients on EMS stretchers, unable to hand over because there are no available beds to put them in on the ED.” A doctor is needing to decide which patient to push out of the resuscitation bay to make space for another emergency case, whilst a nurse is desperately calling the wards trying to find a free bed in a hospital ward. 

Nobody in this situation, or the wider ED holds a complete picture of the department, and the team are facing many issues at the same time, evaluating several situations, interpretations and choices simultaneously. Nobody has the time to ‘gather all the facts’ and then decide what’s going on and what to do next. This may feel familiar, as to many of us the gap between “figuring out what is happening” and “doing something about it” barely exists in practice. 

Karl Weick spent his career studying how people cope with confusion and he gave the phenomenon a name: enacted sensemaking. Basically, it is this idea that we are not only perceiving the situations we’re in, we help create them. 

Weick’s work was one of the key theories underscoring a study we conducted in Cape Town ED’s. The findings are applicable to any situation with high stakes decision-making, flux, and where collective sense-making matters. 

Sensemaking isn’t discovery, it’s enactment

Humans seems to assume that reality is out there, fixed and waiting, and our job is to gather and analyse enough information to see it clearly before we act. Many of the rational economic theories and decision-making theories, even work on willpower was built around the assumption that humans are rational and live in a world that is rational, and if we just figure it out and map the sequence, we’ll be fine. Weick (and other sense-making theorists) challenged these concepts as far back as the early 1980’s. Weick argued that people don’t uncover a pre-existing situation so much as produce the situation they then respond to. Essentially, we often can’t know what’s happening until we engage with it. This is especially true for complex situations.

Weick used the term sense-making to distinguish it from decision-making language that implies a stable set of one-directional sequence of rational options: gather information, see it clearly, choose the best option, act. His research showed that sense-making is messier, and it shows how people actually operate and make decisions in ambiguity: they act, notice what the action produced, tell a story about and the story becomes the ‘situation’ that are then treated as plausible. Thus, enacted sense-making highlights that action, not observation is what gets the whole process moving. Action creates a sense-making loop – act, action produces information, you retrospectively make sense of what you just did, that revised sense reshapes the next action. Thus sensing and deciding are generative, with no clear boundaries.

I have previously written about the features of sense-making in the workplace (link) and just to highlight a few features that are key for this blog:

  1. Enactive of the environment. The environment (organisation/ED) is not separate from sense-making, it forms part of the sense-making; actively shaping interpretation and communication. This is extensively described in Actor-Network-Theory, that proposes that humans and non-humans be treated with equal agency as actants. It can also be linked to Schein’s referral of visible artefacts in an environment as the visible level that shapes organisational culture. As organisations institutionalises behaviours, routines, and creates scripts for what is acceptable behaviour, the environment will prime sense-making before anyone has said a word. 
  2. Social. Sense-making happens through conversation, handovers, meetings and shared language. Thus, what one person makes of an event is shaped by what others around them are saying. In other words, sense-making resides in inter-subjective processes. 
  3. Focused on extracted cues. We simply can’t process every single cue or stimuli in an environment. We select what we respond too, and we do that by paying attention to familiar cues, or cues that we’ve been primed to see – which can be linked back to identity, role, and environment. And once we select a cue, we build a story around it, which could be as simple as this is not important, or this demands immediate attention. Different roles and identities might (will!) see the same situation differently, this is an affordance not a barrier!  
  4. Feedback loops – A team’s identity, its retrospective stories, its social exchanges and its extracted cues all get expressed through what people actually do — and what they do then reshapes the situation everyone is trying to make sense of. Feedback loops are therefore socially regulated within the local interactions and context. 

Thus, enactment in the organisation prime sense-making by providing social cues and structures, it then edits sense-making through social feedback processes and triggers sense-making by posing ‘puzzles’. Enactment sets in motion feedback processes that may produce self-fulfilling prophecies which then become evidence.

Weick’s descriptions of sense-making underpinned a published study I ran across five Cape Town emergency departments. Over eight weeks, doctors and nurses told 84 short stories about moments of interruption on shift, then self-interpreted their own stories using the SenseMaker® tool. We guided them through the self-interpretation by referring to Weick’s process of sense-making. Before considering the findings, let us consider the context and environment of the ED. 

Characteristics of the Cape Town EDs that will influence sense-making:

  • This part of a hospital or facility are in the closest contact with surrounding communities forming an access point into the facility. 
  • The physical structure of the ED is designed to be easily reconfigurable to cope with fluctuating demand or surge. This sounds like a good thing, but it makes it easy to stretch the ED beyond capacity. In the ED’s I studied, it was the norm to have double or triple the number of patients than the unit’s capacity. Not only does this practice outstrip safety rations, but also resource allocation (including staff and consumables) are typically set according to number of beds, not number of actual patients. 
  • Because everything is on wheels, and it is reconfigurable, staff spent an inordinate amount of time searching for equipment, patients are moved – from beds to chairs, from inside a room to the corridor, and time is spent finding patients. 
  • People/patients have unlimited 24/7 access to the ED and can arrive unscheduled, be of any age, with any condition whether it is medical or an injury or major trauma. In other spaces, patients typically require an appointment or referral and the ward is determined by diagnosis and therefor designed to deal with the patient population for example paediatric patients. 
  • Patients mostly arrive without a diagnosis, and the level of intervention differs – some may require immediate treatment, whereas others may able to wait for care, some may require urgent invasive interventions, or advanced diagnostics. 
  • The previous points creates an inherent variability of the ED, where there is constant change, where available information may become rapidly dated – as an emergency case arrives or a patient condition suddenly changes or operational decisions needs to be made regarding resources e.g. staffing or consumables. Or the unit is constantly reconfigured – things move around all of the time. 
  • Information flow within the ED is convoluted and asynchronous. Decisions are made without a complete set of information which clinically could include diagnostic tests, past medical history, patient baseline whereas operationally includes difficulty in estimating staffing needs for the next 12 hours, pharmaceuticals, number of beds required, etc. 
  • The work is by nature interrupt driven and this has been shown to increase the cognitive load, and decision-making density – making it easier to make mistakes or to miss connections between seemingly disparate pieces of information. 
  • In South Africa, the ED becomes busier as the rest of the hospital becomes quieter. This is because many other parts of the hospital functions on business hours, with skeleton staff and limited specialists available after hours. However, evenings and weekends is when the ED’s become busier with acute cases – usually trauma-related injuries.
  • The team is multidisciplinary with the core team being doctors and nurses with distinct task and workload dimensions, yet they remain simultaneously independent and interdependent. They use the same resources, look after the same patients, in the same setting, but have different roles, scopes, identities and reporting lines. 

The results of our study demonstrated how enactment are differing across team members and the differences were marked between levels of experience and also profession. I previously wrote about it here. We found that doctors, especially the more senior and experienced ones leaned toward informal, situational judgement — reading the room and acting on it. Yet, they also indicated that they don’t learn from what has worked previously, especially not intentionally or as a collective. Essentially, they arrive at work every day and they act according to what is currently happening. Nurses were evenly distributed, but when filtered, it showed that lower category nurses leaned toward formal channels and rule-following to manage situations. A point of concern is that the lower category nurses are typically responsible for triage, and by default the waiting room, and if they are unable to respond to what the changing situation requires as they are strictly following rules, it may contributing to the ‘chaos’. 

In your story it was best to do things based on: act on what has worked before/follow the rules and policy/what the situation needed.

In another survey question, that I’ve written about before, both doctors and nurses reported feeling swamped with information and unclear about what that information meant for their next move. When people experience an information overload, they become blinded to additional information, which may result in them ignoring data. When stressed, people revert back to habituated ways, which implies that the habits needs to be created and reinforced prior to experiencing stress or a crises. 

The ability to respond to a changing environment is vested in patterns of interactions, not individual behaviour. Our findings suggested that the conditions for collective sense-making are not enabled in the ED. In bureaucracies (like hospitals), vertical communication and information flow is encouraged, whereas in the ED environment what is required is open communication and information flow across boundaries i.e. a relational bureaucracy. This requires a rethink and instead of focusing on information flow, reporting structures and rules, it should be redesigned to think of adapting to change, open communication and stronger social bonds via huddles etc. 

We published another paper from the same dataset in EMJ, that makes the enactment point even more directly. Participants were asked to tell a story after reading the following prompt: “Whilst showing a new colleague around in the EC, you are interrupted to assist with a challenging situation. When you touch base with the colleague later, they ask how often these types of challenging situations arise and what they should do.” 

After sharing a story, they asked to provide a title and a metaphor. During analysis, war language dominated, participants described the EDs as war zones, staff as soldiers fighting a constant battle, met with “no help” from the rest of the hospital and being set up to fail. That’s enactment in close to its purest form. The metaphor isn’t just a colourful description of a pre-existing reality — it’s part of what produces the reality. I love the way Anne Lamot describes metaphors in her book bird by bird – “ Metaphors are a great language tool, because they explain the unknown in terms of the known”. A department narrated, shift after shift, as a battlefield gets treated like one: staff brace for combat, expect abandonment, and act defensively, protects their information within their tribe (discipline) which in turn reinforces the very story that generated it.

Underneath both papers sits the same mechanism. Enactment sets feedback loops in motion that can become self-fulfilling: an ED primed by chronic crowding and convoluted information produces stressed, defensive stories; those stories get retold and become the lens the team uses to interpret an ambiguous cue; that interpretation shapes the action taken; and the action produces fresh evidence for the story. Across the five departments, we found little sign of shared, collective sensemaking and clear evidence of operational disconnect — a risky combination in an environment built for time-critical decisions. Weick’s answer isn’t “gather more information.” It’s to deliberately shift the stories being told and reset the conditions that prime sensemaking in the first place.

Why this matters beyond the ED

  • Stop waiting for clarity before taking action. Clarity follows action rather than preceding it, this is especially true in complex social realities. This means getting a team to try something small and visible before demanding they agree on “the plan.”
  • Favour plausible, actionable interpretations over perfectly accurate ones — deliberately. In complex, time-pressured settings, insisting on certainty before acting can be more dangerous than acting on a reasonable story and adjusting as you go. This conflicts with the assumption that the accuracy of the managers perceptions and thus decisions is that determines the effectiveness of outcomes. 
  • Pay attention to who’s telling the story, and the words used. Because sensemaking is social and retrospective, the language a team settles on becomes the reality they act on next time. Facilitating better narrative-building is not a soft skill on the side — it’s the intervention. Which stories do we want to keep and amplify and which do we want to reduce, abandon or change. 
  • More on stories: the stories told in an organisation remain embedded, free from chronology or linear sequence and it may even be inherited (i.e. stories about before our time) and accepted without questioning the current validity or even updating. Small nudges in these stories and the daily dialogue can shift the system.
  • Expect different groups to enact different situations from the same event. Different roles in an organisation will act their way into different versions of “what’s happening.” Design for that difference rather than assuming a shared briefing will erase it.
  • Treat the environment itself as an intervention point. Occupancy levels, physical layout, information flow and workload all prime how people enact meaning before a word is spoken. The environment is as important as the human behaviour. Changing the story a team tells often starts with changing these conditions, not just the conversation. 
  • Nurture an attitude of wisdom – accept that no one has a full picture of what is happening right now. In Weick’s words “extreme confidence and extreme caution both can destroy what organisations needs most in changing times – which is curiosity, openness and complex collective sense-making.” Perhaps the leaders’ most important role in complex environments is to create enabling conditions for team members to experiment, to chat, to provide ideas. 
  • People notice what they are conditioned to notice… and as our findings showed – when people experience an information overload, they become blinded to additional information, which may result in them ignoring subtle cues. People are also more likely to return to habituated ways of thinking, which implies that the habits needs to be created and reinforced before the crises – I will write more about this in my next blog. For now, consider how your organisation may be constraining sense-making via feedback loops, information flow and conditioning. 

Conclusion

Sense-making is about the interplay of action and interpretation rather than the influence of evaluation of choice. Organisations contextualise sense-making by imposing cognitive constraints on everyone that is making decision, this is equally as important as staff training, rules etc. Authority alone doesn’t carry people through uncertainty. Shared sense does. 

If you work in a high-pressure team — clinical, operational, or otherwise — I’d love to hear where you’ve seen people enact their way into clarity rather than find it waiting for them. 

Sources

  • Cunningham, C., Vosloo, M. and Wallis, L.A., 2023. Interprofessional sense-making in the emergency department: a SenseMaker study. PLOS One, 18(3), p.e0282307.
  • Cunningham, C., Vosloo, M. and Wallis, L., 2025. It’s a battlefield! A thematic analysis of narratives shared in Cape Town emergency departments. Emergency Medicine Journal, 42(1), pp.3-8.
  • Cunningham C. The adaptive capability of the operational team to respond to challenges in the Emergency Centre. A SenseMaker® study in Emergency Centres within Cape Town.
  • Weber K, Glynn MA. Making Sense with Institutions: Context, Thought and Action in Karl Weick’s Theory. Organization studies. 2006
  • Weick, K.E., 1993. The collapse of Sensemaking in Organizations: The Mann Gulch Disaster. Administrative Science Quarterly. Vol 38, No4 pp628-652
  • Weick, K.E., 1995. Sensemaking in Organizations. Sage Publications.
  • Weick KE, Sutcliffe KM, Obstfeld D. Organizing and the Process of Sensemaking. Organization Science Vol 16, No 4. 2005
  • Klein G, Moon B, Hoffman RR, Making Sense of Sensemaking 1: Alternative Perspectives. Vol 21, No 4, July/August 2006. 
  • Klein G, Moon B, Hoffman RR. Making sense of sensemaking 2: A macrocognitive model. IEEE Intelligent systems. 2006 Oct 31;21(5):88-92.

Discover more from Dr Charmaine Cunningham

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Dr Charmaine Cunningham

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading